Our daughter is a sweet girl. Truly. She loves puppies and kitties. And Princess Stories (don’t hold it against her). When she is sleeping, and I stare at her still, calm face, her delicate eyelashes, her hands folded pray-like, and her slow, measured breathing, I am mystified that this is the same child that when awake can go from zero to sixty in her anger, wreaking havoc on anyone and anything that comes in her wake.
We have been desperate to rid her of these aggressive behaviors. If she doesn’t stop, I am afraid what the ramifications will be. Forget about the “Alice in Wonderland” Tea Party she has requested for her birthday, I’m worried she won’t have any friends at all. Or worse, that she won’t be able to stay in school—where she already receives special supports.
So, we recently renewed the “every fluffy, pink item at the dollar store” behavioral chart, and the very sooner had we started had she come home with, not only an unhappy face, but an “incident report.” And this was a half day. She didn’t even make it through three and half hours before she had spit and hit a little girl in her mainstream class. Tuesday she went for a hat trick and pushed a girl who was trying to steal her seat, slapped a girl who told people about the push, and yelled at another who was also, according to my daughter, “blabbering,” about it.
It is understandable that she has a high amount of frustration and, yes, anger. She struggles with everything: fine motor, gross motor, motor planning (dyspraxia), apraxia, dyslexia, etc. etc. All of these impact her socially, as she can’t “keep up” with her peers. She does not always get those non-verbal cues necessary to make and interact with friends. She thinks kids playing tag are running away from her. She thinks that kids in the ice cream line are laughing at her, when they are just happily talking. Or she is outraged when someone gets in line first, or takes a seat she wanted to sit in. We get a lot of notes home about the way she misinterprets things. And she does…sometimes.
Sometimes…she is interpreting it just right. Sometimes kids are just mean. Yes, she certainly has a tendency to view the world in black and white terms. She wants a seat. Someone else takes it. They’re mean. And of course, my daughter’s reactions are outrageous. Awful. And we need to stop them. We have to give her the tools to handle those situations. But usually when she is being given consequences for her heinous crimes, they are given…in black and white terms. You hit, you’re mean, please say you’re sorry. She apologizes, and the next day we are back to square one.
She hasn’t learned anything other than being wrong. And then being punished. We know that social interactions are more complex than that childhood assertion, “She’s mean.” And sometimes, many times, the other kids are mean too.
Such as the little girl who decided to tell my daughter she wasn’t allowed to use the purple marker. Even though the purple marker was in the middle of the “free pile” and no one else was using it. My daughter, not having the language and tools to defend herself, felt picked on. And she was right. Of course, when my child reacted with anger, the little girl went off with a friend in tow, and tattled to the teacher. Obviously, this little girl didn’t supply her part in the reaction. But she had the language skills and ability to tell the teacher. And to know what details to leave out.
For whatever reason, this little girl enjoyed pushing my daughter’s buttons. She got a little power from being the “protector of the markers.” The teacher even acknowledged this. They asked for both sides of the story, thankfully, because in the past they haven’t, and my daughter has been completely incapable of telling them. And I have seen the other girls whisper about her, or point out that the chicken scratch scribble on her paper isn’t a real “kitty,” or refuse to allow her to join their dance or their games of tag because she is too uncoordinated, too awkward, too odd.
Regardless, this time my daughter had hit and (god help us) spat at this little girl, she was the one punished, although she had been quietly coloring and behaving herself before the girl butted in. Anyone hearing the upshot of the story would say that my daughter is the bully. But, despite my daughter’s horrendous reaction, she wasn’t entirely in the wrong. We felt the need to empathize somewhat with our daughter on this point, while taking a clear stance that she would have consequences for hitting. We discussed tools for defending yourself, words to use, and adults to turn to. Great.
And then she struck again. In the social quagmire of the lunchroom. The very next day, she ended up pushing one girl and then slapping another. The lunchroom is a dreaded place for many kids, but quite difficult for mine, who is not only physically awkward, but slow to process visually, so she is unable to quickly assess a situation and put herself in an advantageous position, or physically agile enough to move around the table. And without a monitor to help her navigate this social marsh. She always ends up with the last seat. At birthday parties, in circle time, and definitely at lunch, when the other more verbally and socially adept have already established lunch plans and cliques. Our daughter is painfully simple. She sees seat near an accepting friend. Not the seats across from or in proximity. She zeros in on a sit and like a beagle on a scent she is singularly focused, and almost always someone beats her to it. And so this time, she pushed the girl who got in her way.
After she pushed the girl, another girl began to relay it to another girl, so my daughter slapped her and told her to stop “blabbering” about it. And when one of the same girls involved in the “marker incident” began chiming in, my daughter told her she was mean, and should also stop her blabbering.
I was heartbroken. Embarrassed. With each line written I felt a small piece of my resolve crumble away. She pushed someone. She slapped another. She yelled at a third. It was three strikes to my heart. How in the world would any of the girls would ever play with her again?
Yet, I felt the injustice for her. I know that she is a sad, socially awkward little girl who just wants a seat in the lunchroom. How many of us can relate to that? Any maybe the other girls should have stopped blabbering about it. She isn’t misinterpreting anything. (Well, maybe some things). But, she’s frustrated. She’s pissed. And I can’t really blame her. Social complexities escape her, which she needs desperately to learn. But ironically, it is almost impossible not to reprimand her in a simple way. Hitting=wrong. If I don’t, I fear where she will end up. Friendless? Homeschooled? Juvie?
Sometimes, at night, I wake up in a sweat, gripped with fears that my daughter will grow up to be a violent criminal. Back in my twenties, I taught at a medium security prison, where one of the inmates had been sent to the hole for stabbing another inmate in the hand with a pencil. All for stealing his canteen candy. He was indignant in his anger. The morose absurdity still sits with me. This is my daughter’s simplistic rational. My brother stole the remote, so I hit him with it. He took my seat at the breakfast table, so I yanked him to the ground. She continually sabotages herself with her angry outbursts. I had sympathy for those inmates for their very stunted view of things. Though certainly felt better with them behind bars.
I can’t deny that there isn’t a small part of me, and perhaps many of us, that hasn’t harbored notions of a little jail-yard justice. Though I’m not going to go around stabbing people who cut me in line at Starbucks. But I’m not misinterpreting things when I’m annoyed listening to grown women stand around at the school drop off, or the sporting event, or the evilest of places, the brownie troop meeting, blabbering about other people. Sometimes I see the closed circles, and the lowered voices, and the snickering, and I want to walk by and shout, “You’re Mean.” Because, honestly, I’m with my daughter…some of them are. Of course, I fight the urge to run them over with my car. So, yes, we are definitely instituting a no hitting policy. But, for my daughter, I’m also going to move to a more complex view of the situation and also take a stand on the egregiousness of “blabbering.” I wholeheartedly agree: Blabbering = mean.